9 Car Rental Brands at La Guardia Airport (LGA)

Satisfied.

Reviewed: Aug 19, 2025

Very satisfied.

Reviewed: Aug 9, 2025

Excellent

Reviewed: Jun 24, 2025

Reviewed: May 13, 2025

Reviewed: Mar 19, 2025

I booked a Toyota Camry but was given a Hyundai instead. However, the car was very new and drove quite well. Returning the car was extremely convenient—just leave the keys inside the car, and that's it!

Reviewed: Aug 17, 2025

Very satisfied.

Reviewed: Jul 31, 2025

The rental company was excellent. They noticed a safety issue with the tires and replaced the car for me.

Reviewed: Jul 19, 2025

There was a long queue, but picking up the car was convenient.

Reviewed: Jun 29, 2025

Reviewed: Feb 12, 2025

Very good

Reviewed: Jul 29, 2025

Fairly smooth process

Reviewed: Jun 6, 2025

Very satisfied, the front desk staff were patient, explained the rental terms in detail, and provided us with an almost brand-new 7-seater Traverse, making our family road trip perfect.

Reviewed: Jun 3, 2025

Very satisfied

Reviewed: Jun 2, 2025

Satisfied with the service.

Reviewed: Feb 17, 2025

Overall, it's quite good.

Reviewed: Mar 17, 2025

Very satisfied

Reviewed: Feb 12, 2025

Pretty good. Pick-up and drop-off were very straightforward and quick.

Reviewed: Nov 3, 2024

Reviewed: Nov 2, 2024

A very satisfying car rental experience.

Reviewed: Sep 2, 2024

Very satisfied

Reviewed: Jul 24, 2024

Great car rental company. You can choose from various models of the same category. Many cars come with an EZPass, so you don't have to spend extra money renting one.

Reviewed: Mar 2, 2024

Overall good

Reviewed: Feb 11, 2017

The store is large and has a complete range of vehicles. Even if you don't speak the language well, gestures will do. Especially when returning the car, it takes less than a minute, it's incredibly fast!

Reviewed: Feb 8, 2016

Excellent

Reviewed: Nov 1, 2021

When I arrived on time to pick up my rental, Advantage did not have any cars. Instead I was told that there was a two hour "waiting list" and that they would call me when a car was available. The staff was nice during what I'm sure was a frustrating day for them, but ultimately Advantage failed at the one thing I counted on them to do: give me a car that I had reserved (and prepaid for!).

Reviewed: Oct 15, 2019

In the contract, it's highly important to arrive at my pick up time on time. I actually got to the place a few minutes early and the staff informed they had no cars available and there were 5 people in front of me waiting on a car. I was offered no compensation for their overbooking and I was not informed that if you leave the state of New York, you MUSt pay a toll to get back in to the state (I opted to not get a toll tag because I had not planned to use the toll on my journeys from NY to NJ and back). The vehicle felt like it had not be serviced in a while as the brakes on the vehicle did not respond as quickly as they should. I would not recommend Advantage to anyone, even if they are the cheapest, which seems to be because they do not service their vehicles and overbook.

Reviewed: Sep 2, 2019

Front desk customer service employee fought with me. Not part of my conversation. They have contacted me about the issue. Very unprofessional. Terrible employees. Customer service means customer service.

Reviewed: Aug 30, 2019

the car was not up to expectations. i feel i deserve a discount for having to wait for a bad car to show up. i left for my trip late and in a car too small to take my packed luggage.

Reviewed: Aug 28, 2019

The customer service representative we had on the return was Tracy. She went above and beyond to help me with checking in the car.

Reviewed: Aug 21, 2019

The Dollar phone representatives were extremely unhelpful. They told me that I could return the car early and receive a pro-rated rate and when I arrived at the counter, I was told otherwise. I ended up returning the car early and paying the full amount. When at that point, I attempted to keep the car, per the original agreement, the counter representative become hostile and verbally abusive.

Reviewed: Jul 15, 2019

Good friendly service - although the place was a little hard to find. Vehicle was excellent. We used it for a shopping trip up to woodbury common - plenty of space for all of us and all our shopping.

Reviewed: Jul 2, 2019

Very thorough in checking documents, so the process was not fast. I was asked if I wanted insurance that included towing fees, but I insisted and they eventually dropped it. Returning the car was very convenient; after a quick round outside, I just handed over the keys, got the receipt, and left.

Reviewed: May 23, 2019

Good company

Reviewed: Mar 6, 2021

The service attitude was decent, and the waiting time was very short.

Reviewed: May 28, 2018